My views on life and meaning (as of 15th
Nov 2026!)
Reward and Punishment. Good and Evil: Making
sense of life while living.
I'm not writing this with a view to changing you or anybody's mind! I respect views held by other people, and the whole purpose of this instalment is to show the difficulties I have had in trying to understand the nature of life, “why me”, morality, right and wrong, is life followed by an afterlife? Etc.
My good friend Nirmalan, in a recent article in the Jaffna Monitor, stated the comfort gained by having two rails in the Journey of life.- https://www.jaffnamonitor.com/two-rails-but-one-track-the-god-within-and-the-god-beyond-in-religious-thought/
His excellent article comparing the two rails of a railway track and suggesting that “The two rails do not meet and neither line needs to absorb or defeat the other. Yet both are necessary for the train of human civilisation to move forward. Hence the question whether ‘God’ is a delusion or an ‘Evolutionary imperative’ shall remain open for now” is a very admirable point of view.
I'm now taking the points of view of three hypothetical people.
Number one – the scientific materialist
A person brought up in the scientific tradition, seeking answers through research, documented studies, and
verified findings. Accepts hypotheses as acceptable with conclusions which are reasonable
in the present state of knowledge, always with the caveat that new evidence
will need a rethink.
Such a person will regard the life of a person as one lasting from birth to death, with death being final. The only concern is this gap- no need extend beyond.
He will have no reason to believe that there is life after death because there are trillions of human beings with just a smattering of records of people recalling a past birth. Even then, to decide between fantasy and reality is not easy. Furthermore, how many stories have been rigorously analysed?
When the planet is swarming with trillions of human beings, I can't somehow regard a single person as very significant with a particular destiny (predetermined). When an aerial view of the planet is seen from a satellite, whole townships, villages, roads etc are visible as tiny spots scattered on the land and in each spot there are thousands of human beings. Any theory of life must take into account the immense size of the human population, even if we for a moment disregard the animal and plant population.
Next I come to the question of how can an individual live his life from birth to death in the most satisfactory way? By satisfactory I mean with least discomfort, least pain and least loss of simple expectations. When death arrives inevitably what matters is how happily he has lived this gap. He has no concern about what happens after death because for him, death is final. His aim will be to find ways of living which promote comfort of mind and body. And for me as that type of person, the Buddhist teaching is exemplary. The universality of suffering (or lack of unchanging comfort), impermanence and the importance of the mind which ultimately determines how you actually feel. Without the mind, the ability to feel, to experience happiness, unhappiness, pain, empathy, reward, pleasure, would not be possible. On the other hand, it also implies that if you don't have that ability you would not experience unpleasant realities also. The sensor measures pleasant feelings and bad ones- no sensor, no pleasant, but no bad either. Or put it differently, if you lose the ability to enjoy pleasure then you lose the ability to suffer pain also which is not a terrible price to pay because pleasures don’t last forever anyway. Such a person will find that accumulation of wealth, power, influence are all transitory and never satisfactory.
That is a Buddhist teaching (about impermanence and desire/attachment )I find very attractive. But this is often misinterpreted as it is not worthy to enjoy a comfort or sensory object which gives you pleasure. What is important is to realize that this is not going to last, it is evanescent (impermanent) like everything. So, don't get attached to it but say ‘yes, this rose is beautiful and I enjoy looking at it but I am fully aware that it’s going to wither away and I don't feel sad when it goes away because that's what I expected’. I think that's the rational view. To me , that is what clinging means and the negative consequences of it.
Thus, the emphasis on not craving for material things such as wealth, power, money and rather, the emphasis on generosity, kindness, empathy, equanimity, as in the four basic principles of Buddhism, I really warm to that. A materialist can accept it as sensible even though he may not accept other Buddhist beliefs such as rebirth.
Number 2- A person who believes there is something after death and that a permanent soul exists. A strict dualist (mind/body) who also believes in the continuation of the mind component after death.
This group includes those who believe that life in some form continues after death. It may be for cultural reasons conditioned by what he has read or heard or been taught. He strongly believes that life cannot just end with death.
He believes that too much has happened between birth and death for death to be the final event. There must be some form of continuation. And this leads to problems of how can this happen and what is the evidence? How can there be a continuation beyond death if the body is what constitutes the person? This leads to the conclusion that mind and body are separate with the body dying but the mind continuing. This is the dualist approach of the famous 17th Century French philosopher, Rene Decartes, also called a Cartesian view.
The next question is about the Nature of this Mind.
Very difficult to define mind. It could be a vague concept like some form of “energy” with nothing definite about how long the mind continues ,or it could be something more definite like the Hindu concept of an indestructible permanent Atman which is embodied for some time on this planet (i.e, You, me) and with death the Athman continues in another existence. This existence cannot be experienced but only accepted. It is a state which the human mind cannot comprehend or experience (like someone who has never seen a mass of water trying to experience swimming). Exactly what form this “Atman-being” (if you call it that), takes I have no idea. But I don't think a traditional Hindu will imagine him or herself as being that person in that world, because what form would it take when you die having lived such a variable time before death. In life from birth to death you're changing all the time. So, if you die at 80 are you reincarnated in the next life as an 80 year old man, or if you die at 10 are you there as a 10 year old boy? Does the age of death matter? There are all kinds of questions raised and you will need to believe that you haven’t got the capacity to fathom with your human brain. The Mind cannot be used as a tool to understand the Mind.
Thus, we don't have the capacity to understand eternal life as a possibility; it has to be an act of Faith. One of the merits of such a belief, where the quality of the afterlife is determined by how you have lived your life, is that it appeals to an instinctive feeling of the existence of justice and fair play in this World. You reap what you sow and you're responsible for what happens to you, even though with the caveat that such a “law” is ordained. It is a neat solution to the question, “is there a Moral law” which is separate from physical ones? If you live by the tenets required thereby, then whatever life that follows will be comfortable; there is personal responsibility to lead a good life.
Number 3- A person who believes that there is something after death but not the existence of a permanent soul.
A Buddhist won’t accept the idea that a person has any component which is unchanging, and therefore a permanent, eternal, unchanging soul is not possible. Even what you call the “person or me or I” is a mental construct and it doesn't really exist as a permanent entity. It has multiple components which arise and fade away related to your perception and circumstances at the time. No person is the same person in that chain. I find it difficult then how such a person can understand good or bad and consequences of acts which have a sort of moral currency attached to them. If that person does something which is not beneficial or kusala then he will reap something which is not beneficial as a “moral” consequence with no clear guidelines as to what is good or bad, and more concerning to me without taking extenuating circumstances. Plato got round this by claiming the existence of absolute moral laws- for example, killing is immoral- period, your intentions and anticipated outcomes do not matter.
The consequence of an action might happen in this life or another life but there's no discernible continuity from a “person” to another. The person who follows you after death has no idea (or memory) at all what his predecessor did. So, how can he feel justified in suffering the discomfort that affects him with no conscious knowledge of any wrong doing he is responsible for? How can he say for example that he is blind because his precursor (who is not him but at the same time him!) did something to justify the blindness? Could he have poked his spear into the eyes of an enemy during a battle in self-defence and made him blind?, which would be very different to a person obliterating the eye of another human being to gain some kind of crude pleasure? This is just an example but I can't see how that responsibility (and deserved punishment) can be felt by the person in this birth for something that happened in a previous birth which he cannot identify as his responsibility.
This does not exclude the possibility of such a continuity.
If it happened to me as Mahendra there is no
way that I could feel justified in my suffering for that because as Mahendra in
this life I had no way of influencing what that person did. But there is a possibility
that this is how the system operates- nothing to do with fair play, punishment
or reward. But in real life this does not appeal to a person as justice or fair
play.
It is not surprising therefore that teachings that postulate a far easy to follow moral law (such as The ten Commandments, the five precepts) would appeal to people, irrespective of whether such laws exist. I may not like it but that could be the way it operates. I may say this is unfair but it is not a question of fairness or not. If your life stream does something which is not good in your previous birth then whether you like it or not the consequences follow.
All I can say is that if there are births that follow when I die even if the connection between me and that next birth is tenuous, I want that birth to be a beneficial one, a happy one. I will therefore continue to do good things because I'm not selfish. I want people to be happy. This is a pragmatic approach with many good points. It is an approach which will promote a better society and for many that is sufficient. Engaging in curious examination is not necessary.
This is my conundrum.
I find it very difficult to believe in moral
laws with absolutes such as killing is always bad, taking what doesn't belongs
to you is always bad (theft), under any circumstances etc. These moral laws are
supposed to operate beyond material laws such as gravity or thermodynamics and
invite speculation of being designed and administered by a supernatural force.
Physical, material things cannot have deep feelings and emotions.
I feel that moral laws like that can exist only if there's something spiritual beyond material phenomena. It could be a god. It could be some kind of superpower but I see no evidence at all to accept this. The question to me then what are morals to a Materialist with no acceptance of the Devine or Spiritual? Would a Materialist therefore be an undesirable person? Can morality arise without spirtituality?
I had a problem addressing this till I found a satisfactory solution when I stumbled on the Theory of Evolution. Evolution is driven by natural laws without any devine powers. How do I explain morality in a physical world with no hidden spiritual forces? What is good and bad, what is good and evil?
Evolution came to my rescue. It is true that the main driving force in evolution is survival. But when you understand that survival cannot happen unless there are good behavioural practices such as cooperation, caring for other beings and extending your life experience beyond yourself, you can see how “moral” behaviour is a potent driver of survival..
For me, morality is a direct consequence of the evolutionary drive for species survival. This operates even in species that are not as advanced as Human beings. You see it in Fish, Reptiles, mammals, birds and even in plant life (where Agency is questionable) but interaction to promote survival is seen. You must have heard of the World Wide Web!
We are part of a huge community. We have to cooperate. We have to help each other. We have to think beyond ourselves and morals are a natural sequence or consequence of the drive for survival. But the behaviour needed for survival is very mechanistic, and therefore the world is replete with examples of bad behaviour. This is to be expected if you accept the theory of evolution. Evolution has no moral dimension, survival is the driving force But indirectly, how we behave does have consequence for survival. Different kinds of behaviour arise randomly and it takes centuries or more for which ones will become more prevalent with time through natural selection. In my world, there is no need to postulate a God or Deity. For those who do, you immediately run into problems of understanding why good things happen to bad people and why bad things happen to good people. This conundrum was once solved in the past by introducing another powerful force, the Devil. There is a constant battle between Good and Evil with an insoluble paradox why the All- Powerful Good is at times defeated by Evil. Sometimes evil wins, sometimes good wins. Don’t question, just accept.
I was born and I will surely die; absolutely certain. In that interval which is just a cosmic dot in the existence of time and the universe, I have to find ways of spending that time in the most comfortable way, which means least amount of pain (emotional, physical). Have the basic necessities of life like a roof over my head, water supply, sufficient income to manage my family, an useful occupation to keep myself occupied, , knowledge and facilities to keep me in good health, the freedom to investigate, question and learn, to live in a safe environment accepting that this requires social agreements on how we interact with each other and free from this sad demand for Individual Freedom (ill-defined usually)and most importantly to be free as far as possible of disease, pain and other man-made discomforts which can befall you. What really matters therefore is how you spend that gap between birth and death.
A thing you can do to avoid suffering is to have a very simple life without expecting too much. Not yearn for power, financial fortunes, unnecessary physical comforts. You just want to be in a state of mind where you feel comfortable with yourself and with your fellow human beings. I would extend that to nature because a man could not and will not survive without protecting his natural habitat, and this has to be an intergenerational point of view devoid of short-termism
In the final analysis, for me that is the aim I have. My morals are built entirely on the fact that human cooperation, human love for each other, care for each other, and understanding humanity are essential components and entirely sensible ones for anybody who wants to live a contented life. It's not because I want to please God or please some supernatural being, not because of expectation or wish to gather merit, or be in the good books of a loving all powerful Deity, nothing like that. In the end, happiness lies in your mind and how you deal with the external world.
The tramp who finds five pounds on the road as he walks could be as happy as the millionaire who adds another million to his stock. You cannot measure happiness like distance or time or objects. It's just a feeling. Events lead to feelings and emotions and you do have come control over them.
Whether you're happy or unhappy, is a state of mind. Try and deal with the continuing barrage of sensory impulses that reach you with what is within your power to deal with. Cultivate your mind to be understanding, non-judgemental and tolerant with the humility that you don’t know everything. Feel comfortable, feel content. Stop planning for your next birth which may or may not be there and try and make the best use of the only time you have- the time between birth and death which is constantly changing.
Thanks for your patience. Feedback is always welcome but please don’t feel obliged.
Mahendra

No comments:
Post a Comment
If you do not have a gmail account, please select your profile from the "Comment as", choose Anonymous from the pick list which appears when you click on the little arrows by the side of the select profile box.